Having just finished reading Inkheart (Cornelia Funke), today, I decided to rewatch the film adaptation. My word cannot be taken for gospel on the subject, because I have only read Inkheart, and neither of the two books that follow it in the trilogy (Inkspell and Inkdeath). However, I feel inclined to burden the world with my opinion, so here goes.
To begin with, Inkheart is an engaging, fun, suspenseful book for teens and young adults. The plot carries the reader strongly and the characters are easy to relate to in many ways. The fascinating idea of being able to read characters, objects, and even locations out of a book is something that Funke took and ran with, much to the delight of my imagination. Vivid descriptions, fiery dialogue, and intense action combine to create one fantastic story.
Looking at the film Inkheart, the reader must be careful. I believe (not having read the rest of the trilogy), that this film is an excellent one-episode story that encapsulates the most important aspects of the book. The story in the movie is accessible to those who have not read the book, and would make an excellent family film.
However, if you are being a purist (which I can be, sometimes), and have read Inkheart, this movie is not for you. There are several pieces of the original story that is missing and/or have been put out of order. Characters get much less development than in the book (but when is that new for a movie adaptation?), specific costumes in the book are not given screen-time, and there are unnecessary or even, disrespectful, moments of humor that irritates the knowledgeable viewer.
In all this, however, there is Dustfinger. Without giving any spoilers, I must say that he is one of my all-time favorite book-to-screen characters. Paul Bettany plays his cowardice, hope, and trickery to a 't' in the film and I couldn't be happier than when he is on screen. I believe that Dustfinger is the most human character in the entire Inkheart story...his passions, hopes, failures, endeavors, and lies all resonate in the deepest part of the reader/viewers' soul. Suffice to say that Bettany's Dustfinger makes my purist heart do a jig of excitement.
...and while you ponder the above, enjoy Dustfinger's awesomeness here.
To begin with, Inkheart is an engaging, fun, suspenseful book for teens and young adults. The plot carries the reader strongly and the characters are easy to relate to in many ways. The fascinating idea of being able to read characters, objects, and even locations out of a book is something that Funke took and ran with, much to the delight of my imagination. Vivid descriptions, fiery dialogue, and intense action combine to create one fantastic story.
Looking at the film Inkheart, the reader must be careful. I believe (not having read the rest of the trilogy), that this film is an excellent one-episode story that encapsulates the most important aspects of the book. The story in the movie is accessible to those who have not read the book, and would make an excellent family film.
However, if you are being a purist (which I can be, sometimes), and have read Inkheart, this movie is not for you. There are several pieces of the original story that is missing and/or have been put out of order. Characters get much less development than in the book (but when is that new for a movie adaptation?), specific costumes in the book are not given screen-time, and there are unnecessary or even, disrespectful, moments of humor that irritates the knowledgeable viewer.
In all this, however, there is Dustfinger. Without giving any spoilers, I must say that he is one of my all-time favorite book-to-screen characters. Paul Bettany plays his cowardice, hope, and trickery to a 't' in the film and I couldn't be happier than when he is on screen. I believe that Dustfinger is the most human character in the entire Inkheart story...his passions, hopes, failures, endeavors, and lies all resonate in the deepest part of the reader/viewers' soul. Suffice to say that Bettany's Dustfinger makes my purist heart do a jig of excitement.
...and while you ponder the above, enjoy Dustfinger's awesomeness here.